What do I do with a received payment toward my credit card?

I don't understand what I need to do with my own payments to my credit card from my checking account (both of which are fed into QB). The debits no longer appear in my checking account feed, leading me to believe that the debit and the payment have already been matched – but what if that's an incorrect assumption? Am I double recording either the debit or the payment if I select "Record transfer" or "Add card payment" via the credit card feed?

Please see the attached screenshot, as this also shows that some payments want to be recorded as transfers and some as payments to the credit card.