Transaction missing in Find Match
I have a sales receipt for $5.00, dated 12/23/2021. I am trying to match it to the bank feed transaction for $4.55 ($5.00 less the $0.45 Stripe processing fee - I typically find the match to the gross amount then add a Resolve Discrepancy to subtract the processing fee). When I click on Find Matches, no matches are found. My date range is 9/24/2021-1/2/2022.
However, when I click on a $9.10 transaction dated 12/22/2021 and click on Find Matches, five $5.00 matches are listed, including the one that is missing on the 23rd.
I have double checked everything. The dates are within range. The account is Undeposited Funds. It is not matched to anything in the register, nor does it have a C or R. I have cleared my cache and restarted my browser. The discrepancy in amounts should have no bearing, especially at less than $4. I've had larger discrepancies show up before.
I am pulling my hair out here. What am I doing wrong?
Sales Receipt:

Matching options for 12/22/2021 transaction:

Matching options for 12/23/2021 transaction:

