Skip to main content
January 6, 2024
Question

Employee Roth Contributions for SIMPLE IRA

  • January 6, 2024
  • 4 replies
  • 0 views

Hello,

 

My name is Logan and I use Quickbooks Desktop. I was wondering how to set up an employee Roth contribution for SIMPLE IRAs. I know that the SECURE 2.0 Act started allowing employee roth contributions to SIMPLE IRA's in 2023. However, when I go into to set up a new payroll items for Roth contributions for our SIMPLE IRA, I don't see an option. All my contributions are currently set up pre-tax (as that is the only option available). 

 

- Is there a way to set up Roth contributions for SIMPLE IRA's?

- If not, is there an update coming soon that will allow this?

 

Thank you,

4 replies

January 6, 2024

Hi there, @Lstall31.

 

Currently, you can only set up SIMPLE IRA contributions in QuickBooks Desktop. This is because a SIMPLE IRA cannot be a Roth IRA as per the IRS. You can read more about the SIMPLE IRA plan on the IRS website.

 

If you wish to proceed with setting up a SIMPLE IRA payroll item, you can follow the steps below.

 

  1. Go to Lists, then press Payroll Item List.
  2. Click the Payroll Item dropdown, then choose New.
  3. Select Custom Setup, then Next.
  4. Select Deduction or Company Contribution, then Next.
  5. Enter the name of the deduction or company matching item, then click Next.
  6. Select the name of your retirement plan provider, or add it, and enter the account number. In the Liability account field, select the account that tracks the deduction or contribution to be paid. Select Next.
    • For company match items, in the Expense account field, select the account that you want to track the item. Select Next.
  7. In the Tax Tracking Type window, select the applicable retirement plan. Select Next twice.
  8. Under Calculate based on quantity, select Neither and select Next.
  9. Leave the Default Rate and Limit fields blank. You can add the rate and limit when you add the item to the employee profile
  10. Tap Finish.

 

Once done, add the items to the employee profile. Here's how:

 

  1. Go to Employees, and then hit Employee Center.
  2. Select your employee.
  3. Select Payroll Info, then add the retirement plan items in the Additions, Deductions, and Company Contributions section.
  4. Enter the amount per period and the limits.
  5. Select OK, when you're done.

 

For more information on setting up a retirement plan, check out this article: Set up or change a retirement plan. You can also find detailed steps on how to edit a plan in it.

If you ever need assistance with filing your taxes using QuickBooks, these resources will come in handy for you:

 

If you have any other concerns regarding setting up a retirement plan or filing your taxes, please feel free to leave a reply below. The Community is always available to offer assistance and support for any additional help you may need.

Lstall31Author
January 7, 2024

January 7, 2025

I have been on chat with QB's and had screen time with the same question for the last half hour.  If the IRS has allowed this option then Quickbooks should set up a new tax tracking type so we can add Roth Simple IRA  to the new deduction.  I have had to add Roth 457 to this Roth deduction in order to remove the federal tax exempt calculation.  

January 7, 2025

Yes, I was on with them for over an hour yesterday. I have also sent the "feedback" that is told to me every time I call 3-4 times. Its extremely frustrating with how much we pay to not have an update that was passed over a year ago. 

 

I may be overly cautious, but I would be careful listing it as a 457 contribution. Rules around the amount of sponsored plans people can contribute to each year, as well as contribution limits (if you have employees who are maxing) could possibly create headaches down the road for you. It may be fine to do, but I personally would not do that for us.

January 14, 2025

This is the response I received from QB support today, ridiculous. 

January 17, 2025

Quickbooks - 

 

Have we had any update on this? I cannot imagine that it would take a more than a week to get updated, especially for a company of your size. 

 

Does anyone have any information they can share on when this is getting updated?

 

JM

January 17, 2025

For now, there's no available updates yet about this, JM1S. However, our product development is doing their best to implement these changes to ensure that QuickBooks Desktop Payroll fully aligns with the new requirements.

 

For now, I suggest sharing your ideas with our product development team. They can evaluate your feedback and consider implementing changes in the next update.

 

Here's how:

 

  1. Locate the Help option.
  2. Choose the Send Feedback Online option.
  3. Select the Product Suggestion option. A pop-up window displays. Enter your feedback suggestion.
  4. Click the Send Feedback button.

 

Once done, our designated team will review it. You can track your future requests through the QuickBooks Online Feature Requests website.

 

Additionally, refer to this article if you want to run and customize payroll reports in QBDT: Run payroll reports.

 

Don't hesitate to comment if you still have concerns about managing your employees. I'm always here to help.

January 24, 2025

We just got in the groove of working with QB time so that it costs into QBO correctly and now you are telling me I have to get a 3rd party app to do my payroll so that our company can utilize a SIMPLE ROTH IRA?     I saw earlier reply from October 2024 that excused the fact that QBO does not offer the  SIMPLE ROTH IRA due to "IRS Regulations"   Well, "IRS regulations" changed on January 1st 2050 & you still do not offer it?   Now we have to find a 3rd party app?  

 

 

 

January 24, 2025

oops! first time posting on this site & replied to wrong thread.  There is another thread on this same subject (not nearly as active)  & QB suggests utilizing 3rd party apps...

 

So glad to find this thread & realize I am not alone & crazy for expecting such huge company to be able to get with the times.  We are sticking with the traditional roth until they do or until we change accounting software..whichever comes first and it is not looking too good for QBO right now!.  Considered using the Roth 401K so tax would calculate correctly and I would just manually monitor that we stay within limits (only a few max so that is doable) and asked QB support it there was a way to change the code on the w-2 on the back end but they said no & I didn't want to chance it.