Let's get this taken care of, @smorgan01.
Thanks for giving detailed information about your payroll item concern. You've done a great job setting up a payroll item for your company paid portion (Health Insurance Contribution). There's no need to create a separate company portion for each employee health insurance. The next thing you'll have to do is simply add the payroll items to your employee's paychecks. QuickBooks Desktop (QBDT) will automatically calculate the amounts. You can browse through this article for more guidance in setting up payroll items: Set up a payroll item for an insurance.
Also, it's easy to view your employee data and monitor your business finances in QBDT. To do so, you can open any payroll reports that suit your needs. To give you a list of those reports and an overview of what data they show, please head to the Excel-based payroll reports page.
If there's anything else I can help you with setting up payroll items in QuickBooks, feel free to leave a reply below. I'd be glad to assist you further. Have a good one.