@MNSTreasurer -
I admire that you are trying to make things better for your employer and glad to help folks when I can see they are first making big effort themselves and know they can make big progress with just a bit of help.
You are correct. Payroll taxes should never be a surprise. Payroll taxes paid by employee and employer are 100% predictable based on employee wages since they are a pre-determined rate as % of gross pay.
Yes, much easier when you are not paying other benefits to employees to complicate payroll deductions.
First must critique organization you work for because Treasury for any entity should require experience, is not like jury duty where anyone s/b able to figure it out on a rotating basis so much risk on internal control.
Then you must know that COA (Chart of Accounts) is simply a LIST of Account Names and Numbers setup.
This is not any kind of a financial report to look at. QB is the only system that whatever reason happens to show account balances for Balance Sheet accounts only. I assume they would be correct but never used.
Sounds like what you want to do, intentionally or not, is to do accrual-basis accounting, where you record employee labor hours for the period x their hourly pay rate to compute gross pay for the pay period end. Since once you know those amounts you can compute the employee and employer payroll taxes today.
This is the other reason I suggest Gusto payroll because you can input those amounts today and see the total amount for payroll and taxes as soon as you have those employee hours and can say exactly how much money you need to pay for payroll in 10 days later. So much easier than computing manually!
My reason for saying that ties directly to the questions you are asking and would provide your answers.
Normally with a 3rd party payroll service, you receive a Payroll Journal, this is a standard report with the standard information needed to post your payroll entries into Quickbooks, if not electronically linked.
Looking at the entries you provided, cannot tell if they are correct unless we know the type of account,
which we can usually tell by the account numbers, so I suggest that before you attempt to correct entries
that you add proper account numbers so they make sense to you and me and others as well; simply add:
1000 Cash (Asset)
2200 Payroll Payable (Liability)
2300 Payroll Tax Payable EE/ER (Liability on Balance Sheet)
5000 Employee Labor Cost (Expense on Income Statement)
6400 Payroll Tax Expense ER Paid (Expense on IS)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To keep simple, say you have two employees. Each paid $10/hour and each worked 40 hours in week.
So $400 each x 2 = $800 Gross pay, right?
09.30.20 Record employee labor from timesheets ideally. Hours worked x hourly pay rate = Gross pay.
-Debit 5000 $800
-Credit 2200 $800
Amount includes employee paid payroll taxes so you can choose to split out but not needed. I don't.
9.30.20 Record employer-paid payroll tax based on labor dollars. See rates on attached cheat sheet.
-Debit 6400 for 7.65% of gross pay
-Credit 2300 for 7.65% of gross pay
10.10.20 Record payroll cash paid to employees as net pay and paid to payroll tax agencies.
-Debit 2200 for EE Net pay
-Debit 2200 for EE paid taxes
-Debit 2300 for ER paid payroll taxes
-Credit 1000 Cash for Total Paid in 3 lines above
These amounts vary slightly in Q1 when you also pay FUTA & SUI and go down if EE pay is over limit.
As they always say, you should discuss with accountant, but this is what I do, so hope it helps.
This is also what my 90 clients do.
Definitely never do this as you noted at bottom of your post:
do the fund get pulled from the checking when you credit them to the liability account, so you need to put them back or credit them back to the checking when making the real payment?
I hope questions make sense and I'm not going in circles.
Thanks so much for any clarification!